Introduction – Why SAP License Optimization Matters Now
SAP’s licensing has evolved into a labyrinth of user types, digital access rules, and hybrid cloud subscriptions. Many enterprises are entangled in this complexity and are paying more than necessary.
In fact, it’s estimated that organizations overpay by 10–30% on SAP licenses simply due to misalignment between what they’ve bought (entitlements) and what is actually used.
License optimization is not about stripping away capabilities – it’s about eliminating waste while retaining full business value. By regularly tuning your SAP license landscape, you can shed “shelfware” (unused licenses), realign license types to actual needs, and avoid surprise costs in audits or renewals.
The payoff is twofold: lower costs without undermining functionality, and stronger leverage when negotiating with SAP. A proactive optimization program ensures compliance, contains costs, and puts you back in control of your SAP spend.
Shelfware Identification – The Hidden Budget Drain
Shelfware refers to SAP licenses you’ve paid for but aren’t using – whether dormant user accounts or entire modules sitting idle.
Even unused licenses incur annual maintenance fees (about 22% of license cost), which means you pay every year for value you’re not getting. Over time, shelfware can inflate costs significantly and create compliance headaches if not addressed.
To expose and eliminate shelfware, take a systematic approach:
- Identify inactive users and modules: Run SAP usage reports (last login data, transaction logs, or SAP’s user measurement tools, USMM/SLAW2) to pinpoint named users who haven’t logged in for months, and any SAP modules or engines with minimal or zero usage.
- Compare licenses vs. usage: For each system, compare licenses purchased to active users. Look for discrepancies (e.g., 500 Professional licenses purchased vs. only 300 active users – that gap is shelfware). Likewise, list out any SAP components you pay for but never implemented.
- Quantify the cost: Calculate the yearly maintenance being wasted on shelfware licenses. (For example, 200 unused Professional user licenses worth €1.2M would incur about €264K per year in support fees.) Tally the total spend tied up in unused entitlements.
- Reallocate or terminate: Plan to reallocate unused licenses to areas of need, or remove them from your SAP contract at the next renewal. Often, this means informing SAP to drop those licenses from support at renewal or negotiating a contract reduction.
Example: A global manufacturer discovered 200 Professional user licenses sitting idle (worth ~€1.2M). By terminating support on them at renewal, the company immediately saved €264,000 per year (22% of €1.2M). That money was redirected to more urgent IT needs instead of being wasted on idle software.
User License Rightsizing – Matching Access to Need
SAP offers several named user license types (Professional, Limited Professional, Employee Self-Service, Developer, etc.), but many companies default to the expensive Professional license for users with only basic needs.
This over-licensing drives up costs unnecessarily. Rightsizing means assigning each user the cheapest license tier that still meets their actual system usage.
For example, a casual user who only runs reports or time entries might need only an ESS license instead of a full Professional license.
To illustrate the cost differences among user types, consider the typical relative costs:
| User License Type | Scope of Access | Approx. Cost (Relative) |
|---|---|---|
| Professional User | Full access across all modules (power users, admins) | 100% (highest cost) |
| Limited Professional | Access limited to certain modules/tasks (departmental users) | ~50% of Professional |
| Employee Self-Service | Self-service only (HR, time entry, basic use) | ~5–10% of Professional |
Rightsizing Steps:
- Analyze usage: Review transaction logs or reports for each user to understand their actual SAP activity.
- Match license to need: Assign each user the lowest license tier that covers their transactions (e.g. ESS for self-service-only users).
- Downgrade where possible: Reassign users from expensive licenses to cheaper ones if their usage is limited (document these compliance changes).
- Validate compliance: Use SAP’s LAW tool to verify your adjusted license allocations and ensure no user is exceeding their new license scope.
By analyzing real usage, you’ll often find that many users can be downgraded without impacting their work.
For instance, if 100 users are all given Professional licenses by default but only 50 truly need that level, downgrading the other 50 to Limited Professional licenses could save tens of thousands annually. The key is to continually align each employee’s license with what they actually do in SAP, rather than over-provisioning “just in case.”
License Pooling & Recycling – Avoid Buying New Licenses Unnecessarily
Many companies continue to purchase new SAP user licenses for every hire or project, while older licenses remain unused.
By implementing a license recycling program, you reclaim licenses from departing or inactive users and reassign them to new users instead of purchasing more. This prevents “license creep” and makes the most of the licenses you’ve already paid for.
Key steps to implement license recycling:
- Centralize license tracking: Maintain a clear inventory of all SAP user licenses owned and who is assigned to each. This oversight (often via your SAM or IT asset management team) prevents the issuance of forgotten licenses.
- Automate offboarding removal: Tie SAP user de-provisioning into the HR offboarding process. As soon as someone leaves or a contractor’s term ends, their SAP user ID is deactivated, freeing the license for reuse.
- Maintain a license pool: Keep a small pool of unassigned licenses ready to allocate. When a new employee needs SAP access, issue one from the pool first. Only purchase a new license if the pool is truly exhausted.
- Audit idle accounts regularly: Monthly or quarterly, check for user IDs that haven’t been used in 90+ days. If the person changed roles or left, reclaim that license into the pool.
Enforcing a “reuse before purchase” policy can significantly reduce unnecessary license spend. You fulfill most new user requirements with existing licenses, and only buy additional licenses when absolutely needed.
Example: Company Y saved €300,000 in one year by recycling 350 SAP user licenses instead of buying new ones during a period of growth. Every time an employee left or a project ended, their license went back into a centralized pool.
When new hires came aboard, the IT team pulled licenses from the pool first. This proactive reuse strategy meant the company avoided a huge true-up bill and kept license count flat despite adding staff.
Contractual Optimization – Negotiate Flexibility Into Your License Base
Sign a smarter SAP contract to improve flexibility long-term. Many terms are negotiable if you push for them.
- Swap Unused Licenses: Negotiate rights to swap shelfware (unused licenses or modules) for other SAP products of equal value that you actually need.
- Cloud Extension: Use SAP’s Cloud Extension program to convert part of your on-premise maintenance into credits for SAP cloud subscriptions (avoiding double payments during cloud transition).
- Re-Tier Licensing: Change your licensing metric if it saves money (for example, moving from per-user licenses to an enterprise or usage-based model that better fits your usage profile).
- Future-Proof Clauses: Include terms allowing periodic adjustments of license quantities or types as your needs change, and cap maintenance fee increases.
- Volume Discounts: If making a large purchase or renewal, demand bulk discounts and ensure maintenance fees are based on the discounted price (not list price).
Example Clause: “Customer may substitute unused on-premise licenses of equivalent value for alternative SAP modules annually without penalty.” This ensures you can reallocate value from unused software to new needs instead of wasting it.
In practice, always enter SAP negotiations armed with data. Know which licenses or modules you’re not using, and which new products you truly need so that you can propose swaps or give-backs. Push for contractual terms that let you adjust your license mix as your business evolves. Every flexibility you negotiate now is a cost (and headache) saved later.
Continuous Optimization – Embedding License Governance
To truly control SAP costs, treat license optimization as an ongoing process. As users and systems change, continuously realign licenses to actual usage to prevent new waste from creeping in.
Key practices include:
- Regular audits: Audit SAP license usage at least biannually (using LAW/USMM or SAM tools) to catch new shelfware or mislicensed users early.
- Stakeholder alignment: Keep IT, Procurement, and Finance on the same page with a shared license dashboard. Log all license changes and share reports, so everyone can see usage versus entitlements and avoid unnecessary purchases.
- Automated monitoring: Use scripts or tools to flag anomalies (e.g., a user exceeding their license scope, or idle licenses >90 days) so you can act before costs mount.
- Post-change true-ups: After any major reorg, acquisition, or system change, re-evaluate and adjust license allocations (and retire any now-unused licenses) to maintain an optimal license footprint.
Organizations that bake these practices into IT governance see the benefits compound. You not only save money year over year, but you also avoid last-minute audit surprises by managing compliance proactively.
Over time, a governance-driven approach can sustainably reduce SAP software costs by 20–30% without any loss of functionality. The business keeps running at full steam – you’re just not paying for excess capacity you don’t use.
Tools and Services to Support Optimization
Automation and expertise can accelerate optimization. SAP’s LAW and USMM tools help gather usage data and identify license needs. Third-party solutions (e.g., Snow, Aspera, ServiceNow) can further analyze usage and compliance.
Many firms also use independent SAP licensing advisors for audit preparation or contract negotiations, and some opt for managed SAM services to continuously monitor licenses.
These tools and services should complement your internal efforts, not replace them – use them to validate your data and uncover savings opportunities you might miss.
Case Snapshot – From Overspend to Optimization
To see these strategies in action, consider Company Y, a European logistics firm that was paying for more SAP software than it used.
They launched a focused 90-day optimization project:
- Shelfware purge: Identified ~200 idle user accounts and five unused modules, cutting about €400K in annual support fees by terminating their maintenance.
- Rightsizing & recycling: Downgraded many users from Professional to cheaper license types, and implemented a license recycling program so that licenses freed by staff departures or divestitures were reused for new hires instead of buying more.
- Contract wins: Using their usage data, they negotiated a swap of unused module licenses for new SAP analytics tools. They also secured a clause allowing ~15% user count adjustments at each renewal without penalty.
- Governance embedded: They embedded a quarterly license audit into IT governance to maintain compliance and continuously capture new savings opportunities.
Result: In two years, Company Y reduced total SAP license costs by 30% with no loss of functionality or compliance issues. This structured optimization effort delivered significant savings while actually reducing risk – the company went into its next SAP audit confident and fully in control.
Related articles
- Identifying Unused SAP Licenses: How to Find and Quantify Costly Shelfware
- Rightsizing SAP User License Types: How to Cut Costs by Matching Users to Actual Usage
- SAP License Reallocation & Recycling: How to Maximize Utilization and Stop Buying Unnecessary Licenses
- SAP License Swap & Trade-In Programs: How to Turn Unused Licenses into Real Value
- Continuous SAP License Management: How to Sustain Optimization with Governance, Reviews, and SAM Tools
5 SAP License Optimization Tactics to Remember
- Identify and eliminate shelfware before maintenance renewals – don’t pay support for unused licenses.
- Rightsize user licenses to match real usage – avoid giving everyone expensive licenses if a cheaper one meets their needs.
- Recycle licenses internally before buying new – reclaim licenses from departures or idle accounts to fulfill new demands.
- Negotiate flexibility in contracts – include swap rights, cloud conversions, and favorable terms at every SAP renewal.
- Make optimization continuous – treat SAP license management as ongoing governance, not a one-off project, for sustained savings.
Read about our SAP Services.
